To Juice or Not Juice … That is the Question

Juicing has become a chic viable contender in the diet industry over the past several years. Controversial because it’s not as healthy or sustainable as eating fresh fruits, and vegetables which are filled with vitamins, antioxidants and minerals. So if your diet includes only fruits and vegetable juice, without other food for several days, that’s an extreme approach that can do more harm than good.

A nutritious juice can be beneficial for your health. Limiting your diet to strictly juices for weeks is not the magic solution the fanatics are claiming it to be. Moreover, there is very little research to support the health claims made by juicing companies.

Juicing is the process that is blended instead of pressed, which extracts out most of the healthy fiber and some antioxidants found in the skins and seeds of fruits and vegetables. For instance, the white pulp in an orange provides flavonoids (antioxidants, anti-inflammatory and immune system) that are left behind.

Fiber has a very important role in the body. It is the indigestible component of whole grains, nuts, seeds, legumes, fruits and vegetables.  Juice doesn’t offer fiber, the body absorbs fructose sugar more easily, affecting blood-sugar levels. Fiber moves quickly through your digestive tract and helps it function properly. It helps reduce constipation and diverticulosis. Fiber-containing foods help provide a feeling of fullness with fewer calories. Meeting the daily recommended fiber intake may reduce your risk of heart disease and diabetes, and help lower your cholesterol.

Research shows that whole fruits are more beneficial than juice for preventing diabetes, and help satisfy daily fiber requirements. Substituting juice with banana, apple and orange resulted in a 25% to 32% increase in fiber, research suggests.

Many juice diets involve consuming no protein at all, or at most a very small amount which is not sufficient for the proper functioning of your body. Your body needs a daily supply of protein to build healthy immune cells and regenerate muscle tissue. Reputable nutritionists believe that juicing diets are not harmful for a few days, but someone may well get sick if continued due to the lack of fiber and protein.  This could affect older adults who are more susceptible to infections, because they may already have lowered protein stores.

While juicing is probably low-calorie compared to chips and sodas, it is still a very concentrated source of calories. For example, a cup of pineapple is about 83 calories, but a cup of pineapple juice is 120 calories. You might not realize how much sugar you’re consuming when you drink fruit juice. In fact, 8 oz. of apple juice contains 29 grams of sugar, whereas 8 oz. of cola contains only 27 grams of sugar. The truth is that juicing diets load you with empty calories. Allowing too many can fill you up without supplying the nutrients your body needs to function properly. When done for 10 days, the empty-calorie intake could send the body into starvation mode, meaning it will try to conserve calories by slowing down your metabolism, resulting in difficulties losing weight in the long term. When people exclude their favorite foods from their diet for a period of time, they tend to reward themselves afterward, which can often lead to overeating. The vast majority of calories taken off during the juicing diet plan are mostly water weight, and will probably be gained again once your everyday eating habits resume.

In other words, you cannot simply drink your way to health and your dream weight.

Dr. Luiza Petre is a Cardiologist and medical director of three Medi-Weightloss® clinics (newly opened Manhattan location at 115 East 57th Street, Suite 1450), physician-supervised weight loss program.  Medi-Weightloss clinics established in the United States in 2006. Medi-Weightloss® is the weight loss program known as “The One That Works!”. Physicians and medical professionals provide individualized care based on patients’ goals, health, and medical history. The program includes weekly consultations with a member of the medical team that focus on nutrition, lifestyle, and exercise.   For more information go to:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.